pretty little liars death out of sight out of mind 'Pretty Little Liars': Toby's dead?! Or Wilden's dead? We don't know.On the latest episode of “Pretty Little Liars,” one (or more) of the characters was killed. Don’t keep reading if you haven’t watched the episode yet. You’ve been warned.

Oh. My. God. This might be a bigger shocker than last summer’s A-Team reveal. Toby is dead?! When we heard the show was killing someone off this episode, we thought for sure it would be Wilden, setting Ashley up for a possible vehicular homicide charge.

But instead, it looks as though the big “A” (not little “A,” Mona) decided Toby had become disposable and took care of him. Or maybe not.

This is “Pretty Little Liars” and so we have to wonder — is he really dead? Because we didn’t see his face, did we? Nor did we see the E. Lamb photograph at the police station. Maybe this E. Lamb person is the real dead body.

Or Detective Wilden could be the person killed off, since Hanna and Aria decided the best solution to “A’s” deposit of Wilden’s car in Hanna’s garage was sink the evidence. The show definitely implied that Wilden was in the car (presumably the trunk) when it went to the bottom of the lake.

And finally, after Spencer finds whoever’s body it is she found, she goes catatonic and is found the next morning by a hiker. The police take her as a “Jane Doe” to what looks like Radley.

It’d be pretty dark for the show to have Aria and Hanna drown someone in a car, even if it is accidental. It would also be dark to have Toby killed off, but not dark in the same way. After all, the show did kill off Maya. Still, we think Toby faked his death and Wilden is going to show up again.

What do you think, “PLL” fans? Is it Toby or Wilden who’s dead? Both? Neither?

Posted by:Andrea Reiher

TV critic by way of law school, Andrea Reiher enjoys everything from highbrow drama to clever comedy to the best reality TV has to offer. Her TV heroes include CJ Cregg, Spencer Hastings, Diane Lockhart, Juliet O'Hara and Buffy Summers. TV words to live by: "I'm a slayer, ask me how."