Whether your high school’s artsy cheerleader or the prankster who works one cubicle over, they all fall into that safe, sweet category — and they definitely still have heartbreaker potential. Vote for your favorite guy- or girl-next-door type in the polls below.
We’ll narrow it down next week and wrangle your top pics for our Ultimate Crush face-off at the end of the month. To check out all the categories, click over to
our TV’s Most Crushworthy page.
UPDATE: Polls closed! Vote in the next round here.